REVIEW

Poor Things review - Emma Stone transfixes in Yorgos Lanthimos’s thrilling carnival of oddness

Emma Stone as Bella in Poor Things. Photograph: Atsushi Nishijima/ © 2023 20th Century Studios All Rights Reserved

It may only be the third week of January, but it’s hard to imagine that there will be a funnier, filthier or more extravagantly peculiar film this year than Yorgos Lanthimos’s latest picture, his second feature film collaboration with star Emma Stone. To describe Poor Things, which is adapted by Tony McNamara (The Favourite) from the 1992 novel by Alasdair Gray, as creatively uninhibited hardly does justice to the wild, wild ride that this explosively inventive picture takes us on. Driven by a courageous and physically committed performance from Stone, the film follows her journey as Bella Baxter, at the start of the picture a barely verbal blank slate, who embarks on an autodidact voyage of discovery to become the ultimate self-made woman.

Like much in Poor Things, the period is impossible to pin down exactly. The story of Bella unfolds in a parallel past, a gothic, steampunk-infused Victoriana, a world that is distorted (literally – Lanthimos’s enthusiastic use of fisheye lenses warps the contents of the frame) by the patriarchal power disparities in society. Without giving away the specifics, the picture is a subversive spin on Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, with the role of Bella’s creator and guardian taken by unorthodox genius Dr Godwin Baxter (Willem Dafoe). Called “God” by Bella, Godwin bears grotesque scars on his face and body resulting from his childhood experience as the subject of his father’s deranged scientific curiosity – an experience that failed to stymie his own rather baroque quest for empirical facts. When Godwin recruits eager student Max McCandles (Ramy Youssef) to keep a record of Bella’s accelerated progress, her grasp of language expands exponentially.

But Bella’s hunger for knowledge and experience is too voracious to be contained within the walls of Godwin’s mansion. She grasps the opportunity offered by caddish lawyer and man-about-town Duncan Wedderburn (a marvellously hammy Mark Ruffalo) and ventures forth from London, first to Lisbon, then by steamship to Alexandria and finally to a Parisian brothel. As Bella’s horizons broaden, so the look of the film alters to encompass her experiences. The chapter set predominantly in Godwin’s home is black and white, but once Bella ventures forth, the film shifts into colour. But not just any colour – there’s an uncanny, hyperreal quality to the palette that makes each frame look like a hand-tinted piece of Victorian postcard erotica.

It’s an alchemic combination, this continuing collaboration between Lanthimos and Stone, a working relationship that started with The Favourite and will continue with another feature film project, titled Kinds of Kindness. Two talents that could hardly be described as risk-averse in the first place (not for nothing did Lanthimos earn the status as the leading light of Greece’s “weird wave” with his surreal 2009 debut Dogtooth), together they unleash in each other an extra level of uninhibited artistic daring that, one suspects, must be rooted in an uncommon degree of mutual trust.

Nowhere is this more evident than in the physicality of Stone’s remarkable performance. And I’m not just talking about the nudity and the sex scenes, although since Bella approaches her body and her sexuality with the same delight and sense of adventure that she brings to the wider world, there is rather a lot of both. But Stone’s virtuoso use of her body – the way it inhabits space, the way she gradually masters her gangling, string-like limbs, the guilelessly open play of emotions in her face – is one of the most crucial elements in our experience of Bella’s journey.

That journey is supported by a deliciously eccentric score by Jerskin Fendrix. An uneasy, detuned four-note motif played on flayed violin strings opens the film and returns in various incarnations throughout, sounding at one point like a hippo mating with a harmonium. The gradual build of intricacy and sophistication in the music brilliantly mirrors Bella’s intellectual growth.

Equally important is the work of the film’s various design teams and Robbie Ryan’s ever-curious camera. Bella’s appetite for novelty is reflected in film-making that evokes a similar sense of wonder and discovery in the audience. From the quirky flamboyance of Holly Waddington’s costumes to the off-kilter production design by Shona Heath and James Price, Poor Things is an endlessly fascinating carnival of oddness. The production design details are particularly fascinating. The walls of Bella’s bedroom in Godwin’s house are hung with quilted ivory satin vignettes – an elegantly opulent twist on the padded cell.

The world outside, meanwhile, is heavily influenced by art nouveau design. But rather than the flora and fauna that inspired the original artists, here the design takes its cue from earthier themes. Look closely and you’ll notice that phallic imagery abounds, nestling between fallopian curlicues and vulvic buds. It’s a pervert’s playground full of subliminal smut. I can’t think of anywhere I would rather spend my time.

Other Reviews

‘Poor Things’ Review: Monster Mash

New York Times

“Poor Things,” Yorgos Lanthimos’s visually sumptuous and gleefully clever new movie, is so very pleased with itself that it makes a review seem superfluous — well, almost. A phantasmagoric take on the classic Frankenstein story garnished with sour laughs, it tracks the adventures of Bella (Emma Stone), a strange Victorian woman with a childish temperament who has a freakish history, peculiar habits, bizarre surroundings and an attentive if altogether unusual guardian, Dr. Godwin Baxter (Willem Dafoe).

Unhinged yet uplifting, 'Poor Things' is an un-family-friendly 'Barbie'

NPR

Poor Things is a little Alice in Wonderland, a little Wizard of Oz, a little Marquis de Sade and a whole lot of Frankenstein. It also has a lot in common with some of Yorgos Lanthimos' earlier films, like The Favourite and Dogtooth: transgressive sex, sadistic power games and grisly violence.

Christy Lemire Poor Things Review

Roger Ebert

Yorgos Lanthimos seems delighted in depicting extreme behavior within pristine settings, whether it’s the quiet suburbia of “Dogtooth” or the clinical lab of “The Lobster” or the opulent grandeur of “The Favourite.” That glaring contrast between the expectations of decorum and the messy truth of humanity seems to fascinate him endlessly.

Poor Things stars Emma Stone as a horny Frankenstein’s monster coming of age

Vox

Greek director Yorgos Lanthimos is famous for making strange and chilly movies: 2016’s eerie dramedy The Lobster; 2018’s The Favourite, a cynical comedy; movies about power games and humans hurting each other and brutal, unforgiving worlds, shot through with jarring visual non sequiturs (the lobster race in the royal bedchambers in The Favourite haunts me).

‘Poor Things’: See It And Hate Yourself in the Morning

Observer

Poor Things, a surreal mix of science-fiction and pornographic fairy tale by the loopy Greek director Yorgos Lanthimos, may not be the worst commercially intended movie ever made. But it is unquestionably the filthiest. In a chaotic cacophony of mixed reviews, it has been described as weird, exhausting, repugnant, raunchy, garish, demented, twisted and bonkers. Those are the good reviews.

‘Poor Things’ review: Emma Stone mesmerizes in perpetually surprising film

Seattle Times

The most remarkable thing about Yorgos Lanthimos’ “Poor Things” is that despite the fantastical set design and elaborately beautiful costumes and eerily inventive camera work, you leave the film struck by just one simple thing: Emma Stone’s face. Playing a young Victorian woman revived after suicide by a Dr. Frankenstein-ish scientist (Willem Dafoe, his face magically transformed into a hellish jigsaw puzzle), Stone uncannily manages to upstage everything swirling around her; she is this film’s primary special effect. It’s a performance of utter boldness, confidence, strangeness — taking hold of the movie and transporting it, and us, to something higher.

Emma Stone's Filmography

La La Land

(2016)

Mia

Cruella

(2021)

Cruella de Vil

The Amazing Spider-Man

(2012)

Gwen Stacy

The Favourite

(2018)

Abigail

Crazy, Stupid, Love

(2011)

Hannah

The Amazing Spider-Man 2

(2014)

Gwen Stacy

The Help

(2011)

Eugenia

Zombieland

(2009)

Wichita

Superbad

(2007)

Jules

The House Bunny

(2008)

Natalie Williams

Birdman

(2014)

Sam

Maniac

(2018)

Annie Landsberg

Cast List


Emma Stone

Bella Baxter


Mark Ruffalo

Duncan Wedderburn


Willem Dafoe

Dr. Godwin Baxter


Ramy Youssef

Max McCandles


Vicki Pepperdine

Mrs. Prim


Jerrod Carmichael

Harry Astley